Review: Once in a Great City: A Detroit Story

Once in a Great City, Pulitzer Prize-winning journalist David Maraniss's account of Detroit in the early 1960s, joins his They Marched into Sunlight and Rome 1960 to form what he calls a "sixties trilogy," exploring America's social and political history during that turbulent decade. This addition is a sobering portrait of a city that felt itself to be at the peak of its power and influence in a "time of uncommon possibility and freedom when Detroit created wondrous and lasting things," even as the forces that would topple it had set about their work.

The principal strength of Maraniss's book lies in his skill at marshaling copious research to serve his sophisticated account of a complex, vibrant city balanced on its tipping point. Detroit's economy in those days was propelled by a robust automobile industry that "gave blue-collar workers a way into the middle class," as it churned out full-sized cars while shrugging off early warnings of competition from the compact models of nimbler foreign competitors.

Boasting a population approaching 1.7 million in 1960, Detroit soon faced the unintentionally destructive force of urban renewal and demographic realities like white flight, which would propel a population decline to barely 40% of that figure by the time the city filed for bankruptcy in 2013. Though these factors were evident to scholars, they were ignored or misperceived by local political and business leaders. In hindsight, their earnest efforts in support of Detroit's failed bid to host the 1968 Summer Olympics, as Maraniss describes them, seem almost comical in their naïveté.

Maraniss effortlessly blends deft treatment of these sociological and political issues with vivid portraits of the colorful characters whose energy drove Detroit during this period. From famous figures like UAW president Walter Reuther, his adversary (and occasional ally) Henry Ford II and Motown founder Berry Gordy Jr., to the lesser known but no less important civil rights leader Reverend C.L. Franklin (Aretha's father) and George Edwards, liberal state supreme court justice turned chief of police, Maraniss portrays a dynamic and engaged leadership pursuing agendas they believed would assure prosperity and racial harmony for their beloved city. Only a few years later, the devastating 1967 riots mocked their efforts.

Recent developments give some reason to hope that, as it emerges from bankruptcy, a much smaller and humbler Detroit will rebound from the worst of its decline. Sadly, one can't avoid the conclusion that never again will it be the city David Maraniss portrays with empathy and candor in this impressive book. --Harvey Freedenberg, attorney and freelance reviewer

Shelf Talker: Journalist David Maraniss offers a vivid portrait of Detroit at the peak of its power and influence in the early 1960s, even as it began decades of decline.

Powered by: Xtenit