Evil-ish is a diverting and inventive graphic novel that explores what it means to find your place in the world while being your authentic self.
Hawthorne Vandecast, who works as a potion barista, longs to join the "bloodthirsty" Brigade of Shade, an evil organization created to "delve into the untapped potential of grand magic." When the Brigade holds open calls, Hawthorne is convinced their sheer vibe of badassery will get them accepted. Instead, Hawthorne is laughed off the stage while Maple, a flowery and kind shop regular Hawthorne detests, steals the spotlight with a demonstration of her grand magic. Maple, who simply likes Hawthorne, offers help and the duo sneak into the castle to appeal the decision. While petitioning the Lady Wrath, Hawthorne accidentally kills the Brigade leader and is ushered into Lady Wrath's old position. But boss Hawthorne quickly learns that looks can deceive and that both Brigades of Shade and bubbly young women may hide surprising truths behind well-designed facades.
In this debut graphic novel, Tarrell enhances their panels with visual tropes of fantasy, mimicking illuminated script illustrations or depicting bubbling brews spilling over the lines onto the page. Every character and background is a mix of the fantastical and the common, such as a potion shop that looks a lot like a coffee shop. Tarrell's protagonist gains friendship, uses humor, and is forced into honesty in a way that doesn't just explore the divide between good and evil but also invites readers to consider what they want versus what they need. A great read for any fantasy fan and those who love D&D. --Michelle Anya Anjirbag, freelance reviewer