The Greatest Lie of All by Jillian Cantor (Half Life; The Hours Count; Margot; The Lost Letter) is a propulsively paced story of intrigue, romance, and suspense starring two women a generation apart navigating family, love, secrets, and art. In one of their several parallels, each uses a professional pseudonym, so that four names delineate these two character arcs.
Readers meet the young, up-and-coming actress Amelia Grant just after the death of her beloved mother, and in the moment when she discovers her actor boyfriend in bed with his costar. At this low, Amelia is primed to accept her biggest role yet: to play the fabulously successful romance author Gloria Diamond in a biopic. Gloria had been Amelia's mother's favorite; it feels like a sign and a way to be close to the mother she's lost, the only person who had called her by her birth name, Annie.
Heartbroken but determined, Amelia travels from Los Angeles to Gloria's remote Seattle-area home to get to know her subject before filming begins. But "the Gloria Diamond" is distinctly unfriendly, cold, and dismissive. Even as Amelia finds a tentative friendship with Gloria's son, Will ("cute, in an academic kind of way"), she despairs at ever understanding what makes the older woman tick. Gloria's career was built on her famous, brief romance with her late husband, Will's father. But the more Amelia learns, the less convincing that story is. She embarks on an informal investigation fueled by shadowy motives: her desire to play a "true" Gloria Diamond; her curiosity about the nature of love, especially as her mother so appreciated it in Diamond's fiction; and Will's reluctant desire to understand his mother. As she pursues the history of the author once known as Mary Forrester--Mare to her friends--Amelia begins to wonder about her own role in the drama unfolding before her.
In chapters that shift between Amelia's perspective and that of the young Mare, The Greatest Lie of All shines in its plot twists and surprises, and, most of all, its pacing, which accelerates from a slow burn to a heart-thumping momentum. The tension increases, stakes rising as Gloria/Mare and Amelia/Annie must reckon with their pasts to chart their shared present. Danger accompanies every possibility of romance, and family history matters more than it originally appears. Cantor's experienced hand shows in this classically crafted thriller, which will keep its readers tautly engaged to the final scene. --Julia Kastner, blogger at pagesofjulia
Shelf Talker: A young actress takes on the role of a glamorous romance author and gets more mystery--and romance--than she'd reckoned for.