Human Again: The Lost Art of Being Alive
by Dr. Chris Cleave
What does it mean to be alive in the modern world? This is the central question posed by Human Again, Dr. Chris Cleave's timely and beautifully written nonfiction narrative work. Known internationally for novels (Everyone Brave Is Forgiven, Little Bee) that explore the effect of trauma on the psyches of his characters, Cleave, an existential psychotherapist and practicing clinical psychologist, combines neuroscience, insights gleaned from his practice, and storytelling to examine why so many people today feel anxious, overwhelmed, or unable to find joy in their lives. Through his own life experiences and those of others he has counseled, Cleave illustrates how we have become separated from ourselves and the world around us, and offers a remarkably compassionate guide to reclaiming our essential humanity and "making the world itself into our medicine."
At the heart of Human Again is the idea that people who are struggling are not "broken," with problems that need to be fixed. Instead, Cleave suggests that many of the difficulties that people experience now are natural responses to the cumulative pressures of today's world. While we are typically encouraged to treat and repair ourselves in ways that range from becoming more productive to simply changing our mindsets, Cleave argues that our feelings of overwhelm are due to the enormous amount of emotional, social, historical, and personal weight we carry. "Even in the womb," Cleave says, "every human being is already carrying trauma." This collective human trauma, combined with personal history, loss, disconnection, and environmental stress "can suddenly go exponential" and cause us to collapse under our private and human weight. We have learned to cope through escapism, busyness, and resignation, Cleave says, but these strategies are limited and often destructive. Rather, we need to understand "the art of living with the human weight: not to change, but to cover the human condition."
To this end, Cleave explores 10 important relationships that shape human life, all of which can be used as "medicines" for our human psyches. These relationships include those with our bodies, brains, work, transactions, place, planet, history, other people, childhood, and individual choices. Cleave considers each with extraordinary insight and gifted storytelling, using examples from his own life, his practice, research, and philosophy. In discussing our relationship with history, for example, Cleave points out how the legacy of intergenerational trauma affects the way we view ourselves as individuals. "We need to grieve our history, in order to free ourselves and our descendants," Cleave states. "This is how the history of the world becomes medicine for our minds."
When it comes to understanding our relationship with the human race, he writes, "Madness always begins when a society reduces our ability to have unmediated contact with humans of varied outlook." When our access to alternative viewpoints is limited by media monopolies or propaganda, we become disconnected from each other and thus destabilized. "And as disconnected people instead grasp disembodied ideas to anchor their minds instead, individual distress suddenly coalesces into collective insanity," Cleave states, adding, "This is when people start wearing brown shirts or red hats."
It is in his discussion of our relationships with our brains, however, that the title of this book becomes particularly meaningful. He believes our wildly accelerated society has caused people to forget how to live as human beings. Technology, consumerism, work culture, social expectations, and constant demands for productivity can make life feel like an endless attempt to keep up. The solution, Cleave posits, is not to become better at coping with these constant pressures, but to reconsider whether the pressures themselves are compatible with human needs.
There is so much to recommend in Human Again, such as Cleave's extraordinarily empathetic and gentle approach, and his ability to present abstract concepts in a lyrical and relatable way. Perhaps the most appealing aspect of the book, however, is its rejection of shame. Cleave explains that we are so often taught that we can improve our lives if only we work harder, exercise more discipline, or follow the right system that when our attempts founder, we are left feeling guilty and ashamed as if we have personally failed. By reconsidering our relationships, the circumstances that have shaped us, and our very humanity, we realize that our burden is shared and we can let go of feelings of shame. This is a tremendously freeing and genuinely hopeful message that will likely resonate with all readers. This is not to say that, as individuals, we are absolved of responsibility but, as Cleave so eloquently guides readers throughout, our first task is to simply slow down and reconnect with ourselves and the world. This is a simple yet challenging concept as we have been trained to continually perfect ourselves, but as this compassionate and beautifully written book illuminates, only through rediscovering how to live can we become human again. --Debra Ginsberg








