The Best Children's Book Ever?
On Friday, the BBC released "The Top 11 Children's Books of All Time," the results of a poll conducted by culture columnist Jane Ciabattari. The winner: Charlotte's Web.
What makes a book stay with us? My top choice is The Little Prince. I remember where I was when I first read it, on the floor of the small living room of our Cape house in Dearborn, Mich., pencil in hand, attempting to draw a boa constrictor swallowing an elephant. Each time I returned to The Little Prince, I understood more of what the narrator told me.
M.C. Higgins the Great by Virginia Hamilton is also on my list. My mother brought it home with a shiny sticker on the front (my first Newbery book) and an Athena Book Shop bookmark inside. It was the first novel I'd read about a fellow Midwesterner, and I loved the way Hamilton described M.C.'s Ohio landscape as observed from atop his 40-foot pole.
Where the Wild Things Are makes my list (#3 on the BBC's), and so does A Hole Is to Dig, with Ruth Krauss's flowing text and Sendak's free and whimsical debut artwork. And let's not leave out books of poetry, like Honey, I Love by Eloise Greenfield ("Made me a poem/ Still got it/ Still got it") and Karla Kuskin's Dogs and Dragons, Trees and Dreams ("Write about a radish/ Too many people write about the moon").
All of the books on the BBC's list deliver to readers a complete world, whether historical, visual or fantastical. Ten years from now, Harry Potter will no doubt make the list. The books that stay with us are the ones we return to over and over. A life-changing friendship between a spider and a pig, a pilot and a prince--and the knowledge that even when that friend is gone, they leave us with treasured words of wisdom. --Jennifer M. Brown, children's editor, Shelf Awareness




